Hosted by     Web page will no longer be updated. This is an archive only. 
Campaign reviews and designer notes 

There are more and more new campaigns; many players want to know "what is a good campaign to play next?"; many campaign designers want to know "what do people think of my campaign?" This section contains your reviews of campaigns, these can be anything from a simple comment on a campaign (even a few lines) to a complete scenario-by-scenario report with screenshots. If you are a campaign designer, I am also happy to include notes about your own campaign - which may help others design even better ones. 

For reviewers; submissions can be text or HTML and can include screenshots or other images - whatever format is easiest for you. I will post almost any review to this site that seems fair (if you are critical of anything, try to make it constructive criticism) - also you should avoid giving away any campaign secrets. 

For readers; please be aware that reviews may be written by someone whose first language is not English - I will make basic corrections of spelling but not of syntax. If you have a problem, please contact the writer of the review. I will post reviews in any language - but I can only read English!

How to submit a review; please do not send me anything that may be copyrighted elsewhere by someone else.

As a start, here are some examples from
PG2 Builders Paradise and Wargamer.com (the Wargamer review is particularly good and detailed).


Reviews and designer notes:

  1. Review of: Red Army Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Andreas Seidel
    Review submitted by:
    Anton Gei▀litz
    Date submitted: 05/31/00

  2. Review of: Polish Forces by Andreas Seidel
    Campaign Designer: Andreas Seidel
    Review submitted by:
    Anton Gei▀litz
    Date submitted: 05/31/00

  3. Designer notes for: Romanian Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Jorge Gabitto
    Notes submitted by:
    Jorge Gabitto
    Date submitted: 6/25/00

  4. Designer notes for: Reich Defense Campaign v1.0
    Campaign Designer: Jorge Gabitto
    Notes submitted by:
    Jorge Gabitto
    Date submitted: 7/15/00

  5. Review of: Reich Defense Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Jorge Gabitto
    Review written by: Dave Anderson
    (Review taken from
    Builders Paradise forum)
    Date added: 10/02/00

  6. Review of: Legions of the Duce
    Campaign Designer: Bjoern Neuhaeuser
    Review written by: Fotis Zografos
    Date added:
    11/10/00

  7. Review of: Onward to Defend Berlin Campaign
    Campaign Designer: G. Francesco Chini
    Review submitted by:
    Jorge Gabitto
    Date submitted: 11/16/00

  8. Review of: Historical German Africa Campaign (demo version, campaign later renamed "DAK Campaign")
    Campaign Designer: Ernst Wiltmann
    Review submitted by:
    PAT
    Date submitted: 11/16/00

  9. Review of: Historical German Africa Campaign from a cheaters viewpoint (demo version, campaign later renamed "DAK Campaign")
    Campaign Designer: Ernst Wiltmann
    Review submitted by:
    J.J.Himes
    Date submitted: 01/22/01

  10. Review of: Historical German Africa Campaign (demo version, campaign later renamed "DAK Campaign")
    Campaign Designer: Ernst Wiltmann
    Review submitted by:
    Matthias Von Oelhafen
    Date submitted: 01/23/01

  11. Review of: Ernst Wiltmann's DAK Campaign (version 1.0)
    Campaign Designer: Ernst Wiltmann
    Review submitted by:
    Andrew Diekmann
    Date submitted: 02/15/01

  12. Review of: US North Africa Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Steve Brown
    Review submitted by:
    Evan
    Date submitted: 03/21/01

  13. Review of: Hungarian Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Matti 
    Review submitted by:
    General Mannerheim
    Date submitted: 04/04/01

  14. Review of: Rommel's Panzers in Africa
    Campaign Designer: Matti 
    Review submitted by:
    General Mannerheim
    Date submitted: 04/04/01

  15. Review of: Soldier of Fortune
    Campaign Designer: Bill Dickens 
    Review submitted by:
    Evan
    Date submitted: 04/16/01

  16. Review of: US North Africa Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Steve Brown
    Review submitted by:
    Paul the Wanderer
    Date submitted: 04/17/01 +

  17. Review of: Unternehmen Barbarossa (revised)
    Campaign Designer: Traveler (original) and Maarten Folkers (revised)
    Review submitted by:
    Paul the Wanderer
    Date submitted: 05/06/01 +

  18. Review of: Spanish Civil War
    Campaign Designer: Antonio Leal-Inglada
    Review submitted by:
    John White Jr
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  19. Review of: Division Azul
    Campaign Designer: Sotirios Thymodeas
    Review submitted by:
    John White Jr
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  20. Review of: 7.Panzerarmee
    Campaign Designer: Dave Anderson
    Review submitted by:
    Jesper Damgaard
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  21. Review of: Polish Campaign
    Campaign Designer: Andreas Seidel
    Review submitted by:
    John White Jr
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  22. Review of: Blitzkrieg!
    Campaign Designer: H. Craig Miller
    Review submitted by:
    Jesper Damgaard
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  23. Review of: Guderian's Gambit
    Campaign Designer: Doug Hone
    Review submitted by:
    Jesper Damgaard
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  24. Review of: Hitler's Last Bastion
    Campaign Designer: Frank Chini
    Review submitted by:
    Jesper Damgaard
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  25. Review of: Unternehmen Barbarossa
    Campaign Designer: Traveler
    Review submitted by:
    Jesper Damgaard
    Date submitted: 09/19/2001

  26. Review of: 1.SS Leibstandarte
    Campaign Designer:
    Matt von Oelhafen
    Review submitted by:
    Frank Zander
    Date submitted: 12/16/2001

Home